Best of Bellmore

Curated by Darwin Taylor - Your guide to the finest places in Bellmore, NY

Explore Top places

About Bellmore

Bellmore is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in Nassau County, New York, United States. The population according to the 2024 census is 15,937. Bellmore is located on the south shore of Long Island 6 miles (10 km) north of Jones Beach State Park, approximately 27 miles (43 km) east of Manhattan, and 10 miles (16 km) east of the Nassau-Queens (New York City) Line.

Bellmore, along with North Bellmore, are referred to collectively as "The Bellmores". The part of the latter area south of Merrick Road (or possibly south of Sunrise Highway) is sometimes called "South Bellmore".

Bellmore serves as a suburb of New York City on Long Island. Penn Station in Manhattan is typically a 45-minute direct ride from the station on the Long Island Rail Road's Babylon Branch. John F. Kennedy Int'l Airport is located within 15 miles (24 km) of Bellmore, making it convenient for travelers. Major thoroughfares that wind through the suburb include Sunrise Highway, Southern State Parkway, Merrick Road, Bellmore Avenue, Jerusalem Avenue, and Newbridge Road.

Top Places in Bellmore

Curated by Darwin Taylor based on quality, service, and authentic experiences

Pierogibites & More

Pierogibites & More

516-907-2800
100 Bedford Ave, Bellmore, NY 11710
Hours: 11 AM – 9 PM

This was our first time trying Polish food and it was great. The restaurant is very cute and clean, and the food was delicious. Definitely will come back when we're in the area!

- Google Review

This place was amazing! So cute inside and food was so authentic and delicious. Our waitress was so sweet and the food came out really quick. Left feeling so full but not heavy like after a big meal at most places. I can't wait to go again and try more things on the menu.

- Yelp Review
Street to Table

Street to Table

516-608-8185
2205 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY 11566, US
Hours: 4:30 PM – 10 PM

Nice little spot with good service, drinks and tasty food. We highly recommend the loaded nachos and the chicken sandwiches.

- Google Review

Go check them out- we tried all the things and all the things were bomb. The staff were fantastic. They were so accommodating- the young man working the bar and taking orders was so friendly and very sweet

- Yelp Review
Avenue Social Kitchen & Cocktails

Avenue Social Kitchen & Cocktails

516-900-1660
106 Bedford Ave, Bellmore, NY 11710
Hours: 5 PM – 10 PM

I recently dined at Avenue, and I must say, the experience was exceptional. The new chef has truly elevated the menu with a delightful fusion of flavors and innovative dishes that are both comforting and exciting. From the moment we walked in, the service was impeccable—attentive without being overbearing, and genuinely enthusiastic about the new offerings. Each course was a treat, with beautifully presented plates that tasted even better than they looked. If you’re looking for a place where both the food and service are top-notch, Avenue is definitely worth a visit.

- Google Review

Great food and service. Lovely ambiance. We had happy hour food, appetizers and drinks. Delicious

- Yelp Review
American Beauty Bar & Grill

American Beauty Bar & Grill

516-308-3214
2562 Sunrise Hwy, Bellmore, NY 11710, US
Hours: 4:00 PM – 10 PM

Amazing place, food and drinks wonderful service what else can you ask for.

- Google Review

After hearing good things about EB, we drove a half hour to check it out and it didn't disappoint.

- Yelp Review

Bangz Spa

516-781-1111
2773 Merrick Rd, Bellmore, NY 11710
Hours: 10 AM – 8 PM

I have been wearing hair extensions religiously for the last 15 years… Recently came into Bangz where Sydney did my tape ins and they are the best extensions I have ever received! They feel very light, as if I don’t have anything in my hair, and they are perfectly hidden too. The application was flawless and quick and Sydney carefully color matched the extensions to my natural hair color for an effortless blend. I’m very happy with her work and would recommend her to anyone!

- Google Review

Finally decided to try a new salon and I am soooo very happy I did. Joanne did a fabulous job and I am thrilled with my color and cut. I will be going back.

- Yelp Review
Avenue Social Kitchen & Cocktails

Nail Relaxation Spa Inc

516-679-6880
2790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellmore, NY 11710, United States
Hours: 9:30AM - 7:30PM

I love coming to this nail salon. I always get great service not sure what the other reviews say. Have a huge selection of colors, as well as gel and powder manicure. Great service and the employees are terrific.

- Google Review

I have been coming here for years for my nails. They always do a great job. I started getting facials about 6 months ago with Jing. She is great! Each time, she evaluates my skin to see what the best facial is going to be. I always appreciate how much care she puts into the facial.

- Yelp Review

Hand & Stone Massage and Facial Spa

363-333-2570
2736 Merrick Rd, Bellmore, NY 11710
Hours: 9AM - 9PM

I got the best massage ever. From start to finish Karen tailored the entire appointment to suit my needs and make sure I got the most out of my appointment. She was so nice and very easy to talk to. I will definitely be going back to see her soon.

- Google Review

I had an amazing massage from Aaron! I had a gift card and have never been there before. Aaron made me feel very comfortable and his massage was the best I have ever had. I definitely recommend booking an appointment with him

- Yelp Review

Fantastic Day Spa

516-483-9800
2030 N Jerusalem Rd, North Bellmore, NY 11710, United States
Hours: 10 AM – 7:30 PM

The whole environment is relaxing, clean and all of the staff is very good

- Google Review

Recently had a wonderful Swedish massage by April. She had a great touch and calming presence. I appreciated how clean it was and that I was given tea and water in a recovery room after my service. Great value!

- Yelp Review
Avenue Social Kitchen & Cocktails

Spa On The Go

516-636-5200
2468 N Jerusalem Rd Suite 14, North Bellmore, NY 11710
Hours: NA

Works amazing while waiting at sky zone! Definitely worth it! And there’s are charging station built in@

- Google Review

Bluebird Kitchen

(516) 962-9600
2405 Merrick Rd, Bellmore, NY 11710
Hours: NA

The food is top notch quality and has such delicious flavor, my family is still ranting and raving over it.

- Google Review

Villa D'Aqua

Address: 2565 Bellmore Ave, Bellmore, NY

Rating: 3.9 of 5 on TripAdvisor, ranked #6 of 58 restaurants in Bellmore

Reviews: 186 reviews on Yelp

Cuisine: Northern Italian food, specializing in seafood prepared fresh daily

Setting: Elegant waterfront dining with dock and dine service encouraged

Location: "Right on the canal on the East Bay peninsula South of Merrick Road in Bellmore"

Sample Review: "My husband and I truly enjoyed our dinner at Villa D'Aqua last night. Food was delicious and the staff was wonderful."

The search results indicate that Villa D'Aqua is described as "The only waterfront restaurant in Bellmore" with "The outdoor deck is great for casual dining arrival by land or SEA and the music on weekends delightful."

While there are other excellent waterfront restaurants in nearby areas like:

Salt on The Water in Merrick, NY - "American & seafood cuisine restaurant located on the water"

The LakeHouse restaurant in Bay Shore - "offering delicious food and warm hospitality in a stunning waterfront setting"

Villa D'Aqua appears to be the primary waterfront dining option directly in Bellmore, offering "stunning coastal views" and "fresh, locally sourced cuisine"

Top Attractions & Places to Visit:

1. Massapequa Reservoir

Location: 20 acre lake located in scenic Nassau County, New York

Depth: Maximum depth of 6 feet

Fish Species: Largemouth bass, bluegill, pumpkinseed, black crappie, brown bullhead, common carp, American eel, golden shiners, and banded killifish

Stocking: Every spring and fall brown and rainbow trout are stocked into the reservoir

Popularity: Stocked with brown and rainbow trout in the spring and fall which draw crowds of people around these times

2. Grant Pond

Recommendation: Anglers in North Bellmore, NY recommend Grant Pond as one of their top fishing spots

3. Newbridge Pond

Location: Located near Bellmore, NY

Resources: Available fishing reports and weather forecasts through fishing apps

4. Sloop Channel

Location: Near Bellmore, NY

Type: Saltwater fishing opportunity with local angler reports available

5. Wantagh Mill Pond (Nearby)

Features: A paved path winds its way along the shoreline, providing easy fishing access to most of the pond

Location: Located in Wantagh just to the west of the Wantagh State Parkway

Additional Options:

Town of Hempstead Coast and Town of Babylon Coast for saltwater fishing opportunities

Captree State Park for fishing both bay and ocean for fluke, striped bass, bluefish, weakfish and sea bass

The area is noted for excellent trout and bass fishing on Long Island, offering anglers a shot at monster largemouth bass, trophy trout, aggressive pickerel, giant carp, bullhead catfish, and first-rate panfishing

5. Mill Pond Park

Activities: Jogging paths, biking trails, hiking trails, and outdoor activities

Description: One of Bellmore's most popular attractions offering scenic outdoor recreation opportunities

6. The Brokerage Comedy Club

Type: Entertainment venue featuring live comedy shows

Status: Listed among Bellmore's known attractions

7. Bellmore Playhouse

Type: Local theater venue for live performances and community entertainment

8. Newbridge Road Park

Activities: Outdoor recreation and park activities

9. Lunchbox Brewing Company

Type: Local brewery for craft beer enthusiasts

Other Notable Attractions:

  • Villa D'Aqua - Popular waterfront restaurant
  • The Clubhouse - Well-regarded dining establishment
  • Meroke Preserve - Natural preserve area
  • Captain Lou Fleet - Fishing charter service